Comments on Wells’ “In Defense of Mechanism”

A 2006 paper attempting to criticize some of Rosen’s arguments, entitled “In Defense of Mechanism” by A.J. Wells [1], was recently brought to my attention. The paper makes a lengthy series of erroneous arguments based on misinterpretations of Rosen’s arguments. Wells begins with a list of statements drawn from Rosen’s … Continue reading

Wolfram awards his 2,3 Turing Machine Research Prize

  Update 10/26:  Some interesting discussions regarding this award are occurring on the FOM list.   From Wolfram’s 2,3 Turing Machine Is Universal! October 24, 2007–Wolfram Research and Stephen Wolfram today announced that 20-year-old Alex Smith of Birmingham, UK has won the US $25,000 Wolfram 2,3 Turing Machine Research Prize. In … Continue reading

Remarks on Chu-Ho Fall 2007

Dominique Chu and Wen Kin Ho iterate their previous exercises in misunderstanding and misconstruing of Rosen’s work with their latest paper, “Computational Realizations of Living Systems“, in the Fall 2007 issue of the MIT journal Artificial Life [1]. The abstract: Robert Rosen’s central theorem states that organisms are fundamentally different from machines, mainly because they are ‘‘closed with … Continue reading